A craft beer taproom, modern ciderhouse, and artisan wine bar. Also serving handcrafted non-alcoholic drinks, locally-roasted coffee, and so much more.
Do You Know John?
Style: Pale Ale - American
I AM A PATIENT BOY
Style: IPA - New England / Hazy
Not Dead Yet
Style: Stout - English
First Birthday DIPA
Style: IPA - Imperial / Double
Sabro Porter
Style: Porter - American
Iron Goddess
Style: Sour - Fruited
Rebel Berry
Style: Sour - Fruited
Squash Pumpkin Pale Ale
Style: Pumpkin / Yam Beer
Dortmund Export
Style: Lager - Dortmunder / Export
British Pale Ale
Style: Pale Ale - English
Keep Tickin'
Style: IPA - Session
Pale Horizon
Style: Pale Ale - New England / Hazy
PEST From the WEST
Style: IPA - American
Prezident
Style: Pilsner - Czech / Bohemian
Marlborough
Style: Pale Ale - New Zealand
Symphony
Style: Cider - Traditional / Apfelwein
Pivo Petra Voka
Style: Lager - Polotmavé (Czech Amber)
Peanut Butter Bänger
Style: Stout - Imperial / Double
Dungeon Master
Style: Porter - American
Todos Santos
Style: Sour - Fruited Gose
Love Language
Style: IPA - New England / Hazy
Last Caress Nitro
Style: Stout - English
TripelB
Style: Farmhouse Ale - Saison
Hidden Depths
Style: Pale Ale - Fruited
Nightmare of Brew York 2026
Style: Stout - Imperial / Double Milk
Aquanaut
Style: Pale Ale - Other
Cotinus
Style: IPA - New England / Hazy
Stacks
Style: Stout - Imperial / Double PastryUntappd is a new way to socially share and explore the world of beer with your friends and the world. Curious what your friends are drinking or where they're hanging out? Just check their profile where you can toast and comment on their beers!
Ready to start drinking socially? Get the Untappd app here!
The Old Shoe, a bold and unconventional bar tucked away in Orchard Square, has officially been crowned Sheffield CAMRA's Cider Pub of the Year 2025. Opened in 2023, the pub has quickly made its mark by pairing a fearless drinks menu with a welcoming, knowledgeable team - earning high praise for its unique approach.
Founded by Matt Beety, owner of The Bear on Abbeydale Road, and Mike Pomranz, formerly of The Cider Hole in Kelham, The Old Shoe set out to combine "accessibility with bravery." That vision has clearly paid off.
The bar specialises in its own brewed ciders and an ever-changing list of rare cask and keg beers. But it doesn't stop there - its shelves are lined with artisan ciders, natural wines from lesser-known regions, and fruit wines made with unexpected ingredients. For those who prefer to take their drinks home, four fridges are stocked with a wide array of bottles and cans ready for takeaway.
CAMRA judges highlighted the bar's diverse cider offering but also noted its broader appeal, including locally-roasted coffee, a solid selection of non-alcoholic drinks, and a laid-back atmosphere soundtracked by vinyl records. A monthly comedy night adds further character to the space.
The Old Shoe is still evolving. The team has plans to expand into the building's upper floor, with a new bar concept intriguingly named "Not Open Dont Come". A licensing application has been submitted to Sheffield City Council for late-night opening hours, and a planning request outlines the conversion of the former Schuh staff room into a vibrant new space with one full-time and six part-time employees.
For now, though, The Old Shoe is celebrating its recognition as Sheffield's top cider pub - a win for fans of quality, curiosity, and craft.
We have added a new listing for The Old Shoe in Orchard Square. The Old Shoe is a city centre craft beer taproom, modern ciderhouse, and artisan wine bar.