If you'd like to review a pub, we'll add it to the Sheffield Pub Guide web site. All you have to do is click on the link below and fill in one simple form!
The views and opinions expressed below are those of the reviewer and are not endorsed or necessarily shared by Sheffield Pub Guide.
Guests can sip on a choice of drinks such as the classic Aperol Spritz, Pink Gin Fizz, a Bakewell Tart Bellini or their own Rooftop Garden
Been to The York at Broomhill a number of times with my Dad for lunch or with my mate Mat for the start of our Broomhill / Ranmoor / Nether Green pub crawl.
We all like the decor and staff are very welcoming. Dad and I both think the food is very good and fairly priced. We have now been there 3 or 4 times in the past 3 or 4 months, finding the staff and food consistently spot on.
I usually drink Guinness and it is not available, but a porter is sold and makes a pleasant change not like some I have tried in the past.
- Graham Braithwait,
Booked a buffet for 20 people to celebrate my mum 's 90th birthday. This was set in the conservatory. The staff were friendly and efficient. The buffet was excellent value for money. A good time for all.
- M Batty,
This pub has a fabulous atmosphere, good wine, excellent range of beers and good live music.
On the downside, since the new owners took over, the pub is cold! No heating on throughout the night. You have to keep your coat on and hope it warms up as it fills up.
We go in on Saturdays and for the last few weeks have heard many customers commenting on how cold it is. Even the youngsters are putting their coats back on!
- Anne Hutchinson,
The Roebuck Tavern - what a class experience of beer, service and humour - how pubs should be. And the food was also very good. I wish the pub was in Devon where I live.
Take a visit early evening and enjoy a Guinness or two, great music on the jukebox, relaxed and it's got a vibe about it hard to find these nowadays. Congrats from a guy who knows what it takes to get it right.
- Darren Meacham,
Just been to Arena Square on 16th Jan 2011 and it was overpriced garbage.
£4.25 for chicken skewers - 3 tiny bits of chicken and pepper on a stick, obviously from frozen because the pepper was imprinted on the chicken. Burger and chips was just that with a dollop of bland, tasteless coleslaw, and about 8 chips. Burger from frozen - yuk. £8.99 for about 3oz of frozen chicken with a scabby piece of cheapo bacon on, with the saltiest over-processed bit of stuff they call cheese on.
Overall the worst food I have ever had presented by surly, disinterested people. Everything was from frozen and was so over priced. Also decor was cluttered and done on the cheap.
Please stay away from this place it's utter cheaply produced crap. Marks out of 10, -10. Not happy, Jam.
- Jamie Naylor,
This is a traditional local pub, with all benefits of a night club due to a fantastic function room, which I may add is free to hire, with fantastic dance floor, separate bar, and late licence.
Just like to say the last 4 months at this pub have been great, since Lucy, Roxy and Richard came from Merry Monk.
- Carl Disney,
Friendly staff and good service.
Food was absolutely awful - undercooked fish in leathery batter, bullet-hard peas and barely cooked chips.
Would not return unless heavily sedated.
- Cathy Williams,
I squashed in at about 5PM on Christmas Eve to find good ale & good company - what more could you want? Pity the family were busy decorating!
- Eric Watts,
Before I did not like the Pen Nook, but now I love it with a bar and a restaurant. It has just got better now.
- Thomas Chadburn,
The pub is too noisy. There is no atmosphere. I will never come back because the staff are rude.
- Jack,
More reviews: