If you'd like to review a pub, we'll add it to the Sheffield Pub Guide web site. All you have to do is click on the link below and fill in one simple form!
The views and opinions expressed below are those of the reviewer and are not endorsed or necessarily shared by Sheffield Pub Guide.
Party-goers can hit the town and sip on a choice of drinks, dancing the night away at a bar situated in a 19th-century building
Went for a meal on a Monday evening. They had sold out of most of the food on the menu, had to have a chicken dish which was the toughest chicken I've ever eaten. The staff were really apologetic and very nice though.
Returned a few weeks later for a birthday meal wanting to give it a second chance. It was a Saturday night and there were only two staff behind the bar, and one delivering the food. Needless to say they were rushed off their feet. Long waiting times at the bar - fifty minutes for a starter to come out. Half of the food wasn't on the order. We were told they had sold out of most things. Ordered the mains, they had no steaks left. Most of the main courses had sold out as well. Very, very disappointing, as once again the staff were lovely, but it seems that the management quite simply do not order enough stock to meet demand.
Will not be returning nor recommending the Old Grindstone.
- Louise,
Drank, ate and spent the night in their accommodation. We found the whole experience generally good. The selection of ales was splendid, the "ribeye" steaks were done just how we liked them and the meals were delivered promptly and hot. The bar area was busy but you were not kept waiting to get served.
The accommodation is clean but somewhat Spartan (no hanging space, and no shelf in the bathroom).
We thought £40 per night per person was a little dear, as no breakfast is included.
We will use the Robin Hood again.
- Steve Allsopp,
Me and my son called there for dinner on our way from Oldham to watch a football match at Chesterfield. Had two Dambusters which were huge steak and ale pies with home-made chip wedges and vegetables.That and two pints of Coke cost only £13.50.
Best grub we have had for ages and will be going again when we play at Sheffield.
- Rob Fleming,
Lovely old pub, real fire in winter, terrific cooking, including proper roast beef and Yorkshire pud with all the trimmings, just like mum used to make.
Willingly put BOTH cream AND ice cream on my apple pie (personal glutton fetish).
Really good beers, including my favourites, Marston's Pedigree and Black Sheep.
Finish up with probably the best pub coffee in the Sheffield area - usually, two!
This review not a flash-in-the-pan, but based on many happy lunches over the last ten years. Can't walk far any longer, but regularly drive twenty miles to go there for the atmosphere and food.
Plenty of car parking space and they open up an adjacent field on warm sunny Sundays in summer, when it does get busy - justifiably.
P.S. - pretty girls waiting on tables, too - what more can a man want?
- Peter Lloyd,
Fantastic diamond of a pub. Brilliant quality food, very reasonably priced in comparison to any other restaurant I've been to with same quality food. Excellent service, from our lovely female waitress.
Did I mention their real ale choice? Just excellent really well-kept ales, all perfectly served, crystal clear! Bar staff are really informative and know their products. Credit to all the staff there!
Been several times and have never been disappointed. By far the best real ale pub and restaurant in Sheffield.
- R. Armstrong,
We go in the Benjamin Huntsman most Saturday nights but don't know why because the staff just do not seemed to be bothered in serving. They'd just rather talk amongst themselves. Avoid if you want serving quick.
- Paul Marsh,
Such a brilliant bar, and so different to the others which surround it on West Street.
I absolutely love the cocktails, they are so delicious. Me and my friends love coming to The Wick on the weekends because the cocktails are great, there's a really fun atmosphere and a friendly crowd. One of the main things is that its not the sort of place where men constantly letch on you - which can be a problem in other bars. We can get dressed up and have some lovely drinks without being pestered and sleazed on the whole time. Saying that, the men there are worth pulling so it's usually us doing the letching after one too many cocktails!
My friend goes for dinner with her boyfriend at the Wick and is always banging on about how good it is, but I haven't tried it yet myself, as they stop serving food at 9PM.
All in all great bar, definitely try the Seven Hills and the Sloe Down Dear!
- Siobhan Aherne,
We have been going to the Old Horns at Bradfield for some time. The food is great and the staff are so friendly and accommodating. It is such a lovely atmosphere with great scenery. I would recommend it to anyone, carry on the good work John, Cassie and all your fantastic staff.
- Pauline and Gordon Harvey,
What a great pub. Their burgers are fantastic, and they have £2 drinks until Midnight. Definitely a younger crowd in the evening, what with being so close to the university and being situated at the top of West Street, but during the day I find it very pleasant.
- Chazza,
Used to be one of the best pubs in the village until the current landlord drove everyone out with his abusive and rude behaviour.
Would advise anyone to give it a wide berth unless the the current landlord leaves.
- Peter Williams,
More reviews: