If you'd like to review a pub, we'll add it to the Sheffield Pub Guide web site. All you have to do is click on the link below and fill in one simple form!
The views and opinions expressed below are those of the reviewer and are not endorsed or necessarily shared by Sheffield Pub Guide.
Party-goers can hit the town and sip on a choice of drinks, dancing the night away at a bar situated in a 19th-century building
Have been using this pub for years, but I went last Sunday and it was awful. The server was nowhere to be seen, and then when she appeared she stunk of smoke. The food was dry and overcooked. What's happened?
- Richard Moss,
Just returned from the Travellers, Ecclesfield. The food was absolute rubbish.
My order should have come with onion rings, which it did not. My 10-year-old son had a kids meal. He ordered apple juice but they didn't have any so he had blackcurrant. And the chocolate sponge that he ordered initially? We were later told they didn't have this but would do him a warm cookie and ice cream. After waiting 15 minutes for this we decided to leave. My partner's meal was a microwave meal.
I have been before to this establishment and the food has been OK.I won't be going again.
- Lee Herriott,
Been going to this pub for years before the revamp and loved the good old home-cooked food, and the staff were brilliant.
What a disappointment after the revamp. No mashed potatoes or pork crackling with the Sunday lunch, barely warm, even the man who served it didn't have a smile for you. Miss all the lovely grub, the atmosphere and the original staff. Will not be going back again.
- Kathy Goodbourn,
As this pub had been awarded "Pub of the Year" award by Rotherham Council we thought we would give it a try. Big mistake. If this is the best I should hate to see the worst.
When you walk in and look around you can see that it needs a good clean. I ordered a mixed grill, yes there was plenty but tasteless. The meat tasted sour. Chips cooked in old oil. My wife had fish and chips that was the same, tasteless.
Not recommended. Find somewhere else.
- Roger & Maureen,
Have just returned from the Belfry.
Firstly, two members of staff absolutely shone, Jess and Joe (that's when you could actually see Joe, I am sure his surname is blur!). As for Jess, a nicer and more polite person you could not wish to meet. Alas, that's where the platitudes end.
After waiting some 30 minutes for our meal, it became somewhat tiring. However, it did eventually arrive. Similarly when we ordered dessert, again after 20 or more minutes we were faced with the same dilemma, only this time my dessert, including ice cream, arrived on... a hot plate. Not a good recommendation. However, things were amicably resolved.
Look out for these two waiters, attendants or whatever fancy names pubs give them, because they will make your evening more pleasurable.
- Roger W Siddall,
Called in for a pint on Wednesday, as Rangers played at Hillsborough.
Many thanks to Barry and all his staff for being a fine host and making us all welcome, and all his customers who entered into banter and football talk with us away supporters.
A quick pint or two turned into 5 hours and we even returned after the game.
Many thanks and I hope you make us as welcome if the Rangers are down to play the Owls again.
- Dave Martin,
Really disappointed with the revamp, lost all its character. My food was only just warm and not brilliant. The service was really slow and my son ordered ice cream but after over 20 minutes of waiting we had to cancel, as we had to go. Been going to this pub for years but don't think I will be going back now.
- Ann Naylor,
The landlord kept his beer in excellent condition when I last visited over two years ago. His skills stop at the cellar head. Visit this pub to see Basil Fawlty in action.
- Ian Spencer,
What a surprise package this pub turned out to be. We'd not been before, but I guess like lots of people, we'd passed it many times.
Hey, don't pass it by, go in! Friendly, chatty staff, good selection of beers, really good food, a lovely beer garden at the back, and a particular plus on the night that we were there, an impromptu performance from a barbershop choir who it seems rehearse nearby. Their singing got the whole beer garden rocking, a great night. Try to catch them if you plan a visit to this gem of a pub.
- Tim Hilbert,
My family and I embarked on an outing to The Broadfield, despite hearing questionable reviews from friends. We suspended our reservations and visited anyway.
Upon arrival we ordered drinks from the bar, and were told by the lifeless and uninspired staff that food was available to be eaten outdoors. However, when we decided to order food we found the truth to be at variance with what we had been told. The staff were rude and disengaged when my wife enquired about ordering food and declared that they were fully booked after they had clearly told us that food was readily available to be eaten outside.
I am offended and appalled at such treatment of paying customers, especially considering that I had 6 hungry mouths to feed. The irritating attitudes of the staff and the complete disregard of customer service made this "establishment" one of the worst I have yet to come across in Sheffield.
Furthermore, after finishing my flat and tasteless pint, we left enraged and disillusioned. I heard this was once a great pub. What went wrong?
- Mark Middleton,
More reviews: