If you'd like to review a pub, we'll add it to the Sheffield Pub Guide web site. All you have to do is click on the link below and fill in one simple form!
The views and opinions expressed below are those of the reviewer and are not endorsed or necessarily shared by Sheffield Pub Guide.
Party-goers can hit the town and sip on a choice of drinks, dancing the night away at a bar situated in a 19th-century building
My family and I embarked on an outing to The Broadfield, despite hearing questionable reviews from friends. We suspended our reservations and visited anyway.
Upon arrival we ordered drinks from the bar, and were told by the lifeless and uninspired staff that food was available to be eaten outdoors. However, when we decided to order food we found the truth to be at variance with what we had been told. The staff were rude and disengaged when my wife enquired about ordering food and declared that they were fully booked after they had clearly told us that food was readily available to be eaten outside.
I am offended and appalled at such treatment of paying customers, especially considering that I had 6 hungry mouths to feed. The irritating attitudes of the staff and the complete disregard of customer service made this "establishment" one of the worst I have yet to come across in Sheffield.
Furthermore, after finishing my flat and tasteless pint, we left enraged and disillusioned. I heard this was once a great pub. What went wrong? 
- Mark Middleton,
I would like to send a big thank you to all the staff and customer who collected over £75 for the Alzheimers Society in Sheffield. Well done, keep the donations coming! Many Thanks.
- Christine Barnes,
It was our first time & we were greeted by a very friendly barman. Then we ordered our sunday lunch & it came very fast & it was very nice so we are planing to come back with some friends.
There also is a new chef who came to ask if the food was OK & he told us it was his first day & he is planing to do a lot of thing with the menu. P.S. yes the food was top notch.
Many thanks.
- Kevin Wells,
LMAO! Guinness served in a a tall Peroni-style glass! I wonder if they serve their wine in tumblers? Don't go here if you are looking for an appropriately served drink. Laughable if it wasn't for the poor imbibing experience.
- Mark Smedley,
Been to this pub today for the first time, and sadly the last.
Nice pint, reasonable prices, and absolutely, I'm sorry, but, terrible bar staff! If you live local and go here regular, then you will be served at once! If, like today, you're new and attend for a one-off 'special event' then avoid!
This was supposed to bring in new custom, but I'm afraid not in my case. Will be seeking more friendly, welcoming, local pubs. Unfortunately I can foresee this establishment going in the same direction as many other pubs.
- Steve Mills,
I look forward every year to visiting during my real ale trips. Welcoming pub, friendly, knowledgeable hosts and bar staff. Terrific selection of good quality, well-kept ales, served in proper glasses.
Food is excellent and reasonably priced. Marvellous beer garden and have enjoyed the quiz nights and beer festivals.
If I had to pick one pub in the world to call my local, it would be this one!
A real oasis for the discerning drinker.
- Paul White,
Visited the Psalter Tavern yesterday, with 4 in our party. Found the service poor, staff were few and far between, food took an absolute age to arrive, 1 meal was returned under-cooked, refunded lessor amount, no apologies, would not recommend or revisit. Overall rubbish.
- Jonathan Hinchcliffe,
Visited the New Barrack Tavern on bank holiday Sunday and had a great time. Music was great, beer was great and the service was great. Keep it up.
- Becca Price,
Having been in here the service is a disgrace, the bar staff seem to prefer to chat to each other then serve. There are 12 of us go out Saturday night and we will definitely be giving this place a miss.
- Paul Marsh,
Fantastic pub, fantastic grub.
- Liam Weston,
More reviews: