Pub Reviews In Sheffield

If you'd like to review a pub, we'll add it to the Sheffield Pub Guide web site. All you have to do is click on the link below and fill in one simple form!

The views and opinions expressed below are those of the reviewer and are not endorsed or necessarily shared by Sheffield Pub Guide.

Visited this pub at 20:15 on Sunday 14 September 2008 for a meal with my wife and son prior to continuing our journey.

The greeting we received from the member of staff was very cold and off hand. When we went to the bar to place our order the member of staff was very off hand and was less than pleased when we could not tell him our table number, we later found out that this member of staff was the relief manager.

The meals took about 30 minutes to arrive; quite a long time when you consider the pub was almost empty. My wife ordered pork chops, which were very thin and dried up. The gravy arrived in a jug and was cold and congealed, obviously left over from Sunday lunch.

My wife's meal had no potatoes on it and when I asked where they were we were told that there were no potatoes left and that they would cook some chips and make some fresh gravy if she wanted them, which she did. The fresh gravy was cold when it arrived. The attitude of the young lady who served us was one that she couldn't care.

When we complained to the manager (relief) his attitude was similar that he didn't care and offered us voucher to spend in other pubs in the group. The quality of the other meals also left a lot to be desired and needless to say we shall not be eating there again when we visit Sheffield.

- Chas Nicholls, 15/09/2008

Tastefully refurbished, clean and welcoming. Brad is the perfect host, Vick's food is tasty and hearty. The beer gardens are vast. Well worth a visit.

- Mark Simmonite, 04/09/2008

We love to visit the Milestone at Kelham Island and are enjoying working our way through the Gastro Menu. The fishcakes are amazing!

When talking to the young owner, Matt, we were reassured to know that he and his team are dedicated to sourcing local produce and to producing as much as possible in house, e.g. the bread and even the piccalilli!

This gave us the confidence to book into the restaurant, upstairs, for a "fine dining" experience, which was a superb affordable luxury.

- Millie O'Connor, 31/08/2008

We went here after reading a review in Grapevine saying what a great place it was. Bad idea!

It definitely wasn't 'home cooked', and the two of us who ordered from the Indian Buffet (all you can eat) were dismayed to find that in fact there was almost nothing left to eat. The staff weren't particularly apologetic or helpful about this, and the food we did get was very average formula pub-grub.

Two pieces of advice. Don't eat here, and don't trust Grapevine reviews.

- Barry Dobson, 30/08/2008

What a great place to eat, the carvery was fantastic value for money (only £3.50). The place was packed but we got a table and got our meal within half an hour. We would recommend to anyone young or old.

- Lorraine Burton, 23/08/2008

The Old House, which was once called Halcyon, is a pleasant independent bar on Sheffield's youthful Devonshire Street. I have been there a number of times of an evening for pre-club drinks, as the beer is good and I much prefer the atmosphere to the chain bars on West Street. However, it was recently introduced to me as an eatery, and I am a little bit impressed. First I tried the fail-safe option of a burger, which was served somewhat unconventionally in a wholemeal bun, with an onion ring inside. I wasn't too taken by this frivolity, but it was none the less very well made, and the 'fat chips' were sublime. I have also tried a Caesar Salad, which was good, and a steak sandwich, which was excellent. Someone in the kitchen has actually put thought into this.

It gets better, though. Unusually for a bar, the service was very impressive, friendly yet professional and efficient. The sort of people who would give you a recommendation if you asked for it, and really pretend they care. The sort of people you want to be your mates. Many restaurants could learn much from this. The environment is good; 'chilled' it could be described, a bit like a coffee bar in the afternoon perhaps. An old house, I suppose.

But even better is the prices. They range from around £4 to £6 for a main meal and about £3.50 for a sweet, and when compared to the bars and pubs it is competing against, it is very impressive. Drinks prices aren't so competitive, but you can get a pint of Staropramen for £2 between 5 and 7PM. All in all the best value bar food in the centre of Sheffield by far. Even if the burgers are a bit odd.

- James Collins, 20/08/2008

I have worked around Eccy road for a couple of years now and I have spent many of my lunch hours in the Pomona!

It was quite sad to see it go down hill last year and I honestly didn't go in due to the customers and the food was terrible... But it's turned itself around, and now the menu is great and the food is fantastic!

The staff behind the bar are always friendly and considerate. My work team always go there for special occasions (for anything really... because it's a Tuesday!) as it's affordable, great atmosphere and gorgeous food.

I recommend anyone who is around there and a bit peckish to nip in (the other pubs around Eccy road seem to be poor in compared to the Pomona recently!) 10 out of 10!

- Chelsea, 17/08/2008

This was a charming pub, the staff were exceptionally friendly and the food was superb. Peaceful location. Would advise anyone to try it!

- Kerry Byrne, 17/08/2008

The Old House is an excellent place to let your hair down after work, especially with the cheap after work offers that run from 5PM-9PM Monday to Friday. Selected cocktails, beers, ales and wines are all on offer, what more can you ask for?

The food served is second to none in Sheffield and this quality and efficiency is carried on to the drinks range, which is not only expansive but delicious.

The music is a mix of modern day indie and old classics, which I believe works really well to give a really good party atmosphere. 9 out of 10, definitely worth a visit.

- Paul Waterman, 28/07/2008

The Old House, located on Devonshire Street, successfully brings together retro rock and roll and classic Indie to firmly cement itself as one of the coolest bars in Sheffield.

Its drinks variety guarantees something for everyone boasting extensive wine and cocktail lists and over 65 beers from around the world. This coupled with the continually updated music and effective DJs makes for a really pleasant drinking atmosphere early evening building up to a great place to party until 2am on Friday and Saturday nights.

The homemade food is both reasonably priced and of an excellent standard, which makes for an extremely enjoyable place to eat, be it for a quick snack or a three-course meal.

All in all The Old House ticks all the boxes and really is what it claims to be, a home away from home. I would strongly recommend anybody to take a visit as both the home made chunky chips and ginger and lemongrass mojitos really are exquisite.

- James Hallows, 26/07/2008

More reviews: